Pages

Monday, June 20, 2016

Summer moisture for oily or combination skin: Review of Simple Ultra-Light Gel Moisturizer

Disclosure: Affiliate links.
Review of Simple Ultra-Light Gel Moisturizer

I've liked most of the skincare products from the Simple brand that I've tried so far (like the ones reviewed here). They always seem to be exactly as described. No frills, but effective. So when I wanted to find a cheaper alternative to the Paula's Choice Invisible Finish Moisture Gel (reviewed here) that I've been using for about a decade now, this Simple Ultra-Light Gel Moisturizer seemed like a good place to start. I still really like the Paula's Choice stuff, but I'm pretty sure that when I started using it, it only cost $15-18 (Canadian!), and it is now a borderline outrageous $28 a tube. I'll complain about that and other reasons I've been annoyed by Paula's Choice recently in another post, but for now suffice to say that I have been hoping to find a reasonable substitute--reasonable both in performance and price. The Simple Ultra-Light Gel Moisturizer fits the bill at under $10.

Gel moisturizers are wonderful if you have skin like mine: combination, leaning more toward oily than dry, and often dehydrated. My skin regularly feels tight and sort of shriveled while still being oily in places, which is a sign that it needs moisture. (For a really useful explanation of the difference between dry and dehydrated skin, check out this great post from Lab Muffin.) Especially in the summer, traditional lotion or cream moisturizers will feel too heavy and leave my skin greasy as the day progresses. A gel feels lighter and often leaves a more matte finish.

In the winter, however, and as I've got older, my skin has become drier, and I find that lotions are just fine. So when I first tested out this Simple gel moisturizer back in December, I wasn't impressed. Here are the notes I jotted down: "spreads easy, doesn't sting near eyes, very little actual moisturizing--doesn't seem to sink in and hydrate, just smooths a little, skin feels a little tight." So I stuck it back on the shelf and ignored it for several months.

A couple of weeks ago my face started to transition into its usual summer oil slick, and my winter lotion felt too heavy, so I pulled the Simple gel back out. Suddenly it's perfect. Just enough moisture without any greasiness. It's exactly what I need right now. Another thing that is really nice about gel products in the summer is that they feel amazingly refreshing on my skin. Almost like splashing my face with water.

Here's what the Simple gel itself looks like (right), compared to the Paula's Choice gel moisturizer (left). While most gel moisturizers I've tried are translucent like the PC version, the Simple moisturizer is transparent, like hair gel (but not sticky!).

Paula's Choice Skin Balancing Moisture Gel (left) and Simple Ultra-Light Gel Moisturizer (right)
Paula's Choice Skin Balancing Moisture Gel (left) and Simple Ultra-Light Gel Moisturizer (right)
This isn't what I would call a "dupe" for the Paula's Choice moisturizer. The two main things they have in common are the gel formula and the lack of fragrance, which I appreciate. The Paula's Choice moisturizer has a little more slip when you spread it, and it soaks in to create a smooth, matte finish quickly. The Simple moisturizer is just a little tackier. On the other hand, I have to be careful not to apply the Paula's Choice gel too close to my eyes, because it will sting, and I've had no problems like that with the Simple gel. That's a definite advantage.

The Paula's Choice moisturizer has some fancier ingredients like niacinamide,  sodium hyaluronate, and a bunch of antioxidants. The Simple moisturizer does have vitamin E and glycerin, but it's sort of a step down in that sense. Personally, that doesn't bother me too much, because I use other products with more advanced shit in them, and I mainly want my moisturizer to just moisturize. But if you want to limit the number of products you use or buy, maybe a more sophisticated moisturizer is your style.

I also like the packaging of the Simple Ultra-Light Gel, which is a pump bottle. Like this:


Most of the other gel moisturizers I've tried, like the ones from Marcelle and Laneige, come in jars, which I assume is to show off their pretty, translucent texture. I just don't like jars for this type of product. Sure, my hands are clean when I use it, and the preservatives are going to keep it fairly stable, but why not have have as airtight and protected a container as possible? I do actually prefer the Paula's Choice tube, though--it's easier to tell how much product is left, and you can even cut it open to scoop out the last traces if you want to.

If you have skin like mine--not dry, but prone to dehydration--I definitely recommend this moisturizer. I'm extremely happy with it. I just needed to use it during the right season to appreciate it! It's effective, and it feels really fucking nice soaking into my skin on a hot summer day. And it's very affordable. The cheapest I've seen it is on Amazon for $5.56 for 1.5 oz. (i.e. $3.77 per oz. compared to Paula's Choice's $14 per ounce).

Do you find that your skin's behavior also changes pretty dramatically with the seasons, to the point that you have to change products? Any suggestions for keeping the oil at bay would be very welcome!

17 comments:

  1. If you're looking for a gel, I've heard some really good things about the Mizon Snail Recovery Gel Cream, and it looks like it's super affordable. I often see 2-packs on Amazon for around $10. It's something I've been meaning to try out myself.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I use both the Mizon and PC, and I've been really happy with both, they're very similar in texture and finish.

      Delete
    2. That's a good deal! I don't know if I can do snail, though. I'm happy with this, luckily.

      Delete
    3. Ikr. Snail mucus just gross me out. Sometimes I see all the results and scientific evidence and stuff and I'm tempted, but then............ snails. ._____.

      Delete
    4. To be fair, you've positively reviewed cosmetics made with cochineal beetles and crystallized guanine, made from fish scales... snails aren't so icky! :)

      Delete
    5. I'm not a vegan, and it's not a judgement. I find snails gross, and I don't want to put snail slime products on my own face. I realize it's not very rational. (I also have a phobia of moths, and that's even stupider.) It's just a personal thing.

      Delete
    6. Just saw your reply and wanted to add that I didn't mean it as a judgement either (at all!) but text doesn't have any tone, and I probably sounded snarky. I'm sorry! I'm all for do what works for you... and I've got a phobia of eels (?!) So, glass houses and all...

      Delete
    7. Oh no worries! I didn't think it was snarky--I just wanted to clarify.

      Delete
  2. At last! The moisturizer review we were all waiting for!

    When I go to countries in the winter I finally understand why everyone in temperate countries talk about moisturizing all the damn time. I slather on tons of heavy moisturizer. Here though, I can go days without moisturizer without any problems.

    Do bitch about PC! I'm really interested to hear what you have to say. I used to use a lot of PC as well but I've kind of moved on, and of course there were a couple of iffy things in the past few years.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I grew up in a really dry and cold region, and yet I never needed to moisturize regularly until after I turned 30. And when I did use moisturizer, it was just this PC gel. Now I get a little dry in the winter, but I don't know what I would do in a really humid climate. Melt, probably!

      Delete
  3. I want to hear your thoughts on PC in general! My feelings are complex--way too much so considering it's a damn cosmetic company.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ok, I will make that my next post, since I have some notes sitting in a draft right now. Reading Paula Begoun was how I first got into beauty/skincare stuff from a critical angle, and some of the first products I bought, so it kind of feels like an old friend that I've been drifting apart from. If I want to make it extra melodramatic!

      Delete
  4. I've been using Clinique's gel moisturizer since January and I adore it. I've never tried another gel moisturizer so I don't have any basis for comparison, but it does share that splash-of-water feeling and matte finish. It's more expensive than Simple, though, so I might have to give that a try!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've heard that that one is good too, but I've only ever used the lotion version, from back when I was in high school and my mother would buy me the whole Clinique routine with the yellow bar of facial soap!

      Delete
  5. Well, I'll have to put this one on my list. I love gel moisturizers because I have the weirdo greasy yet dry in areas combo skin and regular lotion just seems to grease me up abd I HATE that feeling! I'm currently using both Vichy Iidela (sp?) And neutrogena Hydroboost. I do like both, but a cheaper alternative would be nice! Hell, I wouldn't even be using the Vichy at all except I got it from a sub box lololol

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, for a while I was worried that the only gel options out there were really expensive, so I was glad when I finally found something affordable that turns out to be exactly what I need.

      Delete
  6. Well, I'll have to put this one on my list. I love gel moisturizers because I have the weirdo greasy yet dry in areas combo skin and regular lotion just seems to grease me up abd I HATE that feeling! I'm currently using both Vichy Iidela (sp?) And neutrogena Hydroboost. I do like both, but a cheaper alternative would be nice! Hell, I wouldn't even be using the Vichy at all except I got it from a sub box lololol

    ReplyDelete